32 Comments
User's avatar
Carlene MacMillan, MD's avatar

I read an earlier draft and loved it and this draft has made me cry. Proud of you and it’s true, we have a touch of hypomania to thank for our paths crossing at AACAP a decade ago and becoming intertwined ever since.

Expand full comment
Kelly Roman's avatar

Thanks for sharing this - the public needs more examples of real patients with the disorder than Ye. I cut my RCT teeth with BPII research a decade ago, have personal experience with the disorder, and know how difficult it can be to properly diagnose (and how undiagnosed ADHD can exacerbate the process of simply identifying what's wrong). Following is a link to the BPII research that set the stage for much larger research I just completed that will be published next month - I hope our paths cross soon!: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26414234/

Expand full comment
Mya Dexter's avatar

Just amazing, the right concoction of moving, informative and fascinating. I found you through Leon MacFayden, loved the title of your Substack, and now trawling through your posts as and when I have the time to read uninterrupted. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Thank you so much! It's a podcast too!

Expand full comment
Andrea's avatar

Thanks for sharing, Owen. This should be required reading for all mental health professionals, medical providers, med students, nurses, people, etc.

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Well, it is not without a cost to write, so I'm thrilled if it gets read...

Expand full comment
Steph's avatar

Refreshing truth and gratitude. The mental health field is best with you in it.

Tell oSm his approach to tms saves lives. Bipolar,do you think so?

“Yup”

Expand full comment
Daniel Tagge, MD's avatar

Thanks for sharing bud. Me too. We gonna have to rift about it sometime.

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Thanks! I'd be thrilled for a substack recommendation if you be willing.

Expand full comment
Ashwin Sharma, MD's avatar

Authentic, truthful and honest. Exactly why I’m a fan!

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

It's not always a popular stance

Expand full comment
T. Lawrence Wheatman's avatar

Yet we go on. No regrets.

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

What other choice do we have?

Expand full comment
Lawrence Wheatman's avatar

Plenty! Nationalism, willful Ignorance , lassie fare, selfishness, yadda yadda… But it is hard when you know love is the only answer. No matter what. Now I’m going to YouTube to watch more Russian tanks blown up.

Expand full comment
Jessica C's avatar

Dr Muir, I was lucky enough to come across your article while skimming my emails for CME credits for my PA license. Although I knew this wasn't a CME presentation, I was intrigued and wanted to read the article. It was Excellent and really made me rethink evaluation/diagnosis of patients. Thank you for your openness and candid conversation. I look forward to more.

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

I also spent a lot of time creating cme content for aacap, so I consider this a great honor.

Expand full comment
Jessica C's avatar

Oh wow! That does not surprise me - I say that because your writing was not only informative but also and easy, enjoyable read. (similar to a great teacher). Thank you again.

Have a wonderful weekend!

Expand full comment
Jessica C's avatar

I saved it & screenshot the title. Will definitely be doing this one. Thank you. I'll also Google your name on aacap. Appreciate you :)

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Clinical essentials series. My name is on the committee not the product

Expand full comment
Michelle Bernabe, RN's avatar

your best piece to date!

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Thank you for the gracious response!

Expand full comment
TheMindAndBodyDoc's avatar

Holy cow - I applaud you - even before this post - just getting to know/read you and I am so impressed...but THIS! This is fantastic - reading it in between a busy patient schedule and Im torn from one screen to the next. Havnet finished it yet but HAD TO comment. BRAVO my dude! I wish I had such talent of expression in writing. Never really worked that muscle - trying now in my 'old age'. But again, this is about you, not me - KUDOS. I cant wait to catch up on what ive missed so far and what is yet to come. A bit over the top - but it was my immediate response to reading your post - so its an honest over the top lol. (FYI - already told a pt about some of the resources you have educated me about, so thanks for that too).

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

I deeply appreciate the feedback. This piece took a long time to write. I only started writing about seven months ago, really, thanks to people in my life encouraging me. I would appreciate, if you're willing, a referral on Substack for my newsletter, it drives traffic and that's pretty useful to get the word out.

Expand full comment
Angela Cappetta's avatar

👍🏽

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Vita's avatar

I can validate almost everything you report here so graphically. I wish I that were not the case. As your mother I lived through much of this with you and was largely helpless to do anything to alter the ghastly roll out. Owen, I admire that fact that though you are Job in your way, you don't play the victim. Your story forewarns or explains ex post facto so many things fellow travellers need to know.

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Thanks--dear readers, listen to your mother.

Expand full comment
Mal's avatar

Thanks for your deepest thoughts and courage. I was wondering what medication you are on for BP

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Whatever my doctor says

Expand full comment
Karen King's avatar

Thank you for writing about this. As a psychotherapist, I believe we have a special insight into our clients when we also have and work with our own mental health battles/challenges/ liberators/muses. It's a complicated relationship to navigate and we can understand the nuances our clients face as well.

Expand full comment
Owen Scott Muir, M.D, DFAACAP's avatar

Thank you for the thoughtful comment!

Expand full comment