Nitin Gogtay, M.D. is today’s guest columnist. Prior articles featuring him include “Understanding Kids With Schizophrenia.”
I've written about restraint before as well. Appropriate staffing and appropriate training can make this practice go away. That should be our goal. I'll get off my soapbox, and hand the baton to my colleague!
One day I walked onto our ward, and I saw a nurse sitting next to a child at the dining table. She was holding his hands, and a mental health technician was patiently feeding the child one spoonful at a time. They were both chatting with the child, trying to distract him while convincing him to eat through the fog of voices. I wondered what was going on and asked. The nurse looked up, smiled, and said, “I have to hold his hands because the voices are telling him to punch himself in the face, and then he cannot eat. We need to get some food in because he is on so many meds.”
This was just another Tuesday on our ward. I could describe a hundred scenes like this.
We worked with some of the sickest children that there are – children with childhood-onset schizophrenia – who were actively in the throes of their psychosis – hallucinating most of their waking hours.
Years went by without us using restraints or seclusion on our ward. And if I am being honest, I don’t remember a nurse losing their temper at one of our children.
The Norm Elsewhere
Parents used to be bewildered and couldn’t believe us when we told them we didn’t use restraints. That is not what they were used to. The children we admitted had had many prior psychiatric admissions before coming to the NIH, and for them, physical or chemical restraint, or seclusion rooms, were the norm, sometimes several times in one admission, and sometimes with days spent in isolation.
Seclusion and restraint are not uncommon on any US children’s ward that admits children with severe mental illness. On the other wards where I trained and worked, I would witness them practically every shift, sometimes multiple times a shift.
There are data to show that children are restrained more often than adults on psychiatric units. As a matter of fact, in September a watchdog body in Virginia renewed its call to close the state’s psychiatric hospital for children and adolescents, citing staffing and safety concerns.
What Was Different
So what was behind the success seen at NIMH compared to the other wards I had worked on?
First, on our ward, which housed a maximum of three patients at a time – granted they were extremely ill and needed constant 1:1 or 2:1 supervision – we typically had four to six nurses and mental health technicians. Up to two staff for every child, and the ability to request more. The second was how the nurses had designed the ward to run.
Ratio matters. On the other children’s psychiatric wards I have seen in the US, it is not uncommon to see a single, or at most two, nurses managing 20 or 30 children, maybe along with one or two mental health technicians. On night call, I have seen a single nurse asked to manage an additional ward or two on top of her own. I cannot imagine the burden. The buzzers get pressed at the slightest sign of trouble, ‘as-needed’ medication is given, and seclusion and restraint are initiated. Staff who do not feel safe become fearful, and fear leads to reactions out of proportion to the moment. With so few staff, restraint is often the only way to keep the ward and the children safe, and the cost falls on the most vulnerable children.
How the Nurses Ran the Ward
The NIMH nurses tried something different. As Diane Lawrence, a psychiatric nurse practitioner on the unit, later co-wrote in a conference poster, the aim was “partnered relationships and enhanced interventions that prioritize patient needs and capacity.”
They established ground rules that defined when a nurse needed to step in with restraint: only when there was an unrelenting threat of harm to the child or to others. For example, cursing did not qualify. Even a thrown plate did not necessarily mean restraint, but it always meant a change in the plan: maybe meals in the quieter room away from the noisier lounge area, using paper trays, or moving the target out of reach. These rules were tailored to each child, drawing on everything the team knew about them. They also discussed and documented each child’s triggers, what the aggression was doing for them, and their relationships on the ward. In short, the nurses invested significant effort in understanding each child and meeting them where they were.
All of this required teamwork, collective thinking, and streamlined care. Each patient had a primary nurse, and all communication to the family went through that nurse, so the family never received mixed messages.
It worked. The nurses documented reduced aggression and the elimination of restraint and seclusion in a poster that won second place at the American Psychiatric Nurses Association’s national meeting in 2009.
What Doesn’t Cost Money
It is natural to think that the NIH had resources that most other places do not have. I agree. We did have a staff-to-patient ratio most wards can only hope for. But most of what worked on our ward does not cost money.
Similar ideas have worked elsewhere. A study of 31 adult acute psychiatric wards in England found that simple, relationally designed interventions reduced containment measures, such as restraint, seclusion, and forced medication, by twenty-three percent and overall conflict by fifteen percent. In the US, Pennsylvania’s state hospitals cut restraint and seclusion hours by more than ninety percent over six years by treating restraint as a failure of treatment rather than a treatment and by maintaining adequate staffing and improving training.
Where to Start
What would it take? First, a collective commitment to reduce restraint and seclusion on children’s psychiatric wards. We should start with the data, and require every children’s psychiatric unit to publish its restraint and seclusion rates each year. It would also mean treating adequate staffing as a basic standard of care, not an afterthought, and it would require time and investment in repeated staff training in crisis prevention.
Time, Training, and a Colleague
Diane articulated the sentiment often expressed by our nurses on the unit as “a privilege to be entrusted in the care of these vulnerable children/families and a blessing to see so many favorable outcomes.”
The nurse at the dining table was doing nothing extraordinary. She had three things: time, training, and a colleague beside her. Every child admitted to a psychiatric ward should have a nurse who has all three.
The child described is a composite, and dialogue is reconstructed, and Diane Lawrence is named with her permission.
Nitin Gogtay, M.D., is a psychiatrist who spent nearly two decades at the National Institute of Mental Health studying childhood-onset schizophrenia. His book, The Vanishing Children, will be published by HarperCollins in January 2027. He writes Beneath the Diagnosis on Substack.
I’ve got a new book!
FYI, It’s $0 if you have kindle unlimited. Share it in those group chats of yours!





Hey Owen —
I spent 9 weeks on a locked unit last year.
Well, 2 weeks at first, voluntary, to start ECT. And that was lovely — other patients were kind and relational, staff was terrific.
Fast forward — same amazing nursing staff. Kind, relational, loved each other — from my bed I studied their conversations — their hopes for the future, vacations, families, their conversations with each other. This made me feel secure.
Contrast this with their way of managing issues on the unit in a very matter of fact way —
VIOLENCE WAS DE RIGEUR.
A man hoarded food in his room, which was a threat for vermin. I loved this man — he made beautiful Muslim artwork that took up the entire floor in his room, and I would visit to have him explain it to me. He became loud in defending his food. Six nurses arrived, carried him forcibly down the hall faster than I thought would ever be possible. Into a small room. Hoses, water, screaming. Olanzapine 5 into his… stomach? Is that supposed to go in there? I didn’t see it — however —
After this stuff goes down, the police must arrive, and a report is made. I was in a small room with my mother and a notary, making sure my mother had power of attorney so she could manage my corporation / finances while I was too ill to function. The police outside interviewed the nurses. They had just stabbed the patient who loved food in his stomach with an antipsychotic until he stopped fighting. Three syringes. It then amazed me that I had dinner and coffee with that man later, and he was just fine, as though nothing had happened. He hung out with the nurses who had assaulted him. It was just another normal day for him.
Then there was Beelzebub. A 74 year old woman who was absolutely certain she was the devil. She would run around the unit making gestures and noises at patients, and threaten them. This was a problem. She scared everyone but me. As my roommate, she told me stories of all of the units she had been on throughout her life. Her relationships, what turned her on, the book she was reading. I could speak very little as I was catatonic, but I loved listening to her. I hated seeing her get taken down — three nurses and two security guards would suddenly grab her by her arms and legs and carry her out of our dining room. They would then stab her with syringes in the milieu, in front of all of us. As this was just a normal thing. And then it was over, and then she went back to our room. This happened to her almost daily. She never actually hurt another patient. She had only gestured, but this earned her forced medicine.
OLANZAPINE 5.
EVERY TIME.
EVERY PATIENT.
Because that’s what the pharmacy had delivered to the unit.
Was it what that patient needed? Would be effective? How about just talking to them and having a sitter in front of their room?
WHY ALL OF THESE MEDICATION STABBINGS?
Then there was Aaminah. She was beautiful — and expressive, passionate, and relational. I loved her and how she spoke her truth to anyone who would listen. And when she became psychotic, she became **extremely loud**. So loud. Not hurting anyone, just really freaking loud. For this, she earned time in seclusion. Forty eight hours strapped with leather straps to a metal table, getting stabbed over and over with… you guessed it, olanzapine 5. This didn’t make her quiet. The seclusion room was next to my room. Her voice reverberated throughout my ceiling, my walls, she screamed and screamed for 48 hours. I heard the nurses say “23 syringes”. Didn’t the pharmacy ever run low?
This was a normal day on a unit at University of California San Francisco, on Divisadero Street, on the 7th floor. It was traumatic, for me. More than anything that had happened — actually to me.
When I graduated from nursing school, I really needed more experience in clinical practice (my education had been… everything you hear about nurse practitioner education is actually true). So I took a position running a social model psych urgent care with a nonprofit in my town, San Francisco. I had spent 6 months of my training at Psych Emergency Services at SF General Hospital. And watching takedowns was extremely traumatic for me.
My own unit, Dore Urgent Care, had no institutional police. And we had an open door. I would take in a patient who had been high on meth for 4 days, give them a hug, an eval to make sure I didn’t have to send them to the ED, park them in a big cushy LaZBoy, with a fuzzy blankie, and some Mac & Cheese. I would give them… olanzapine! **Because here it was wanted.** I would help them to feel safe and to sleep. I would have my team place them in an acute diversion unit (ADU), social model temporary housing and treatment, the next day — where that patient was likely to cook meals and, if they were at our ADU next door to my clinic, feed me for the next several days ;-)
I loved my clinic, where I worked for 8 years, serving San Francisco’s homeless. I was assaulted probably 7 times during the time I worked there. That was preferable to me to watching others lose their autonomy, their safety, in takedowns. I saw one only once: a fireman had brought a patient onto my unit, then challenged him. Taunted him. Until that patient got in his face, and he then took the patient down forcibly in my intake area. I told the fireman why this was not acceptable, ever, to happen to any person who was vulnerable and frightened, and I had my staff remove him from my clinic.
WHICH IS WHY NITIN’S PIECE HIT ME SO HARD.
I don’t think the difference between those environments was that one contained good people and the other contained bad people. The nurses who cared for me at UCSF were wonderful. I loved them. They loved their patients. I watched them care for each other. They made me feel safe at a time when almost nothing else did.
And then I watched the same loving people participate in violence that had become completely ordinary inside the architecture of the unit.
That is the part I cannot stop thinking about.
Nitin describes a ward where the nurses had enough people, enough time, enough authority, and enough shared clinical architecture to ask a different question. “Not How do we control this behavior? but What is happening to this particular child, what is the behavior doing for them,” and what can we change around them so that nobody has to overpower them?
THAT IS MEDICINE.
The man hoarding food did not need three syringes because he was a “difficult patient.” He had a relationship to food, and something was happening that made losing it intolerable to him. Beelzebub did not need to be carried out of the dining room every day because she made frightening gestures. Aaminah being super extra loud did not make forty-eight hours strapped to a metal table a treatment.
And olanzapine 5 cannot possibly be the correct answer to every human problem simply because that is what happened to be sitting in the medication room.
The deepest point in Nitin’s essay, to me, is not merely restraint bad / staffing good. It is that staffing changes what clinicians are capable of perceiving. When you have time, training, and another human beside you, BEHAVIOR CAN BECOME INFORMATION RATHER THAN AN EMERGENCY. You can become curious before you become coercive.
I know this is possible because I spent eight years doing it with people who were psychotic, intoxicated, frightened, homeless, aggressive, medically complicated, and sometimes dangerous. I was assaulted. There were real risks. This is not an argument that nobody ever requires containment.
It is an argument that CONTAINMENT SHOULD BE WHAT REMAINS AFTER RELATIONSHIP, CURIOSITY, environmental modification, skilled de-escalation, and adequate human presence have actually failed—not what replaces them because the system has failed to provide those things.
So yes, Owen. Get rid of restraint wherever we possibly can.
But I would go one step farther.
Build systems in which the human beings caring for patients have enough capacity to REMAIN HUMAN THEMSELVES.
Because I have now lived on both sides of that locked door.
AND THE PATIENT REMEMBERS THE DIFFERENCE.
Cara
My son spent 73 out of 99 months in locked wards between the ages of 11 and 19, floridly psychotic for much of it. He described the restraints of “booty juice” (Thorazine shots) and “leather bracelets “ and the humiliation of being denied clothing (I filed a formal complaint with The Joint Commission on that one).